He stabbed her in front of her four children and one of them tried to help her, but he continued to attack her until he killed her without caring about hurting the child. Ten days earlier, on December 28, Hayat had denounced her murderer for threats. The Civil Guard assessed the risk as high and he was arrested, but the judge released him and she left her without protection because she did not want to testify again against her ex-husband. After the police archive, the Civil Guard decided to keep the case active in the Viogen system, but instead of reducing it to low risk, they put it at medium risk with special relevance to be able to call Hayat more regularly. He didn’t give time. Hayat had told the Civil Guard that he assaulted her, even when pregnant. They had a restraining order and they divorced in 2016, but in 2020 they lived together again for economic reasons. In this way, she prevented him from going to prison and they shared expenses. They did not resume the sentimental relationship but they did coexistence. Since then she said that he controlled her. She tried to change shifts at work so she wouldn’t have to coincide at home. She was meeting another man and her ex-husband was harassing her. She had asked him to leave. They are both working and it was no longer necessary to live together, but he refused.